Why Rehab Is Better Than Jail? (Question)

  • In the end, the reason why rehab is better than jail is fairly clear: It gives those with a drug or alcohol problem, who have run afoul of the law, an opportunity to address those problems.

Contents

Does Rehabilitation work better than jail?

Drug rehab is a much better alternative to jail time for many people struggling with addiction. Comparing the benefits of rehab vs. jail time is crucial when looking at those in the system for drug offenses. People who struggle with substance abuse and addiction are more likely to end up with drug charges.

Why is Rehabilitation better than punishment?

Rehabilitation gives one a chance to learn about his/her debilitating problems and offers for one to learn how to change their behavior in order to not commit crime. Incarceration (punishment) puts the offender in a confines of a cell in order for one to think about the crime he/she committed.

Is drug treatment more effective than incarceration?

This policy brief will survey research that shows that, on the whole, providing drug offenders with treatment is a more cost-effective way of dealing with substance addicted drug and nonviolent offenders than prison.

Is treatment better than punishment?

Individuals with substance use disorders benefit more from a rehabilitative approach rather than punishment, and society benefits as well. People in recovery live more productive and rewarding lives. Society benefits from a decreased prison population, reduced crime rates and a healthier population.

Why is rehabilitation important?

Rehabilitation helps to minimize or slow down the disabling effects of chronic health conditions, such as cardiovascular disease, cancer and diabetes by equipping people with self-management strategies and the assistive products they require, or by addressing pain or other complications.

Will rehab keep me out of jail?

Again, it depends on the state, but if you’re attending a treatment or rehab center, you can often get a more lenient sentence or even eliminate any prison time altogether.

What are the disadvantages of rehabilitation?

Cons for Long-Distance Rehab

  • Need for family alliance. Experts continue to recommend the benefit of whole family wellness for addiction treatment.
  • Accessible support systems.
  • Complications with employment leave.
  • Insurance coverage.

How effective is criminal rehabilitation?

Using this method, the existing research, which now involves hundreds of evaluation studies, shows that rehabilitation programs reduce recidivism about 10 percentage points. Thus, if a control group had a recidivism rate of 55 percent, the treatment group’s rate of re-offending would be 45 percent.

What is rehabilitation criminal justice?

Criminal rehabilitation is essentially the process of helping inmates grow and change, allowing them to separate themselves from the environmental factors that made them commit a crime in the first place. This makes some of them commit crimes so they can go back to prison where they know how to survive.

Does the US have the most prisoners?

The United States has the highest prison and jail population (2,121,600 in adult facilities in 2016), and the highest incarceration rate in the world (655 per 100,000 population in 2016).

What percent of prisoners receive drug treatment?

The report found that only 11 percent of inmates with substance abuse and addiction disorders receive any treatment during their incarcerations.

Does rehabilitation reduce recidivism?

Research shows that rehabilitation programs can reduce recidivism by changing inmates’ behavior based on their individual needs and risks. For example, inmates are more likely to recidivate if they have drug abuse problems, have trouble keeping steady employment, or are illiterate.

SAMHSA’s National Helpline

  • What Is Substance Abuse Treatment and How Does It Work? A Booklet for Children and Their Families This program was developed for family members of those who suffer from alcoholism or drug addiction difficulties. Questions regarding substance abuse, including its symptoms, different forms of therapy, and rehabilitation are addressed in this section. This publication addresses the issues of children whose parents have drug misuse or addiction disorders. Addiction to alcohol and drugs may occur in even the most loving of families. This book describes how alcohol and drug addiction have an impact on the entire family. He describes the process of drug and alcohol addiction therapy, how family interventions may be a first step toward recovery, and how to assist children in homes afflicted by alcoholism and drug misuse. It’s Not Your Fault (National Association of Colleges and Employers) (PDF | 12 KB) Assures kids who have parents who misuse alcohol or drugs that “It’s not your fault!” and that they are not alone in their struggles with substance addiction. A resource list is provided, which encourages kids to seek emotional assistance from other adults, school counselors, and youth support organizations such as Alateen, among other places. It Hurts So Much: It Doesn’t Have to Be This Way The organization provides information on alcohol and drug addiction to youngsters whose parents or friends’ parents may be struggling with substance misuse issues. The author encourages young people to look out for one another by talking about their problems and joining support organizations such as Alateen. When There Has Been an Attempt: A Guide to Taking Care of a Family Member Once you have received treatment in the emergency department, Aids family members in dealing with the aftermath of a relative’s suicide attempt by providing information and resources. Provides an overview of the emergency department treatment procedure, a list of questions to ask regarding follow-up care, and information on how to limit risk and maintain safety while at home. Family therapy can be beneficial for people who are recovering from mental illness or substance abuse. This course examines the function of family therapy in the treatment of mental illness and substance misuse. A family therapy session is described in detail, along with the people that conduct them. It also includes information on the usefulness of family therapy in the rehabilitation process. Please visit the SAMHSA Store for further resources.

Treating the root of the problem: Why rehab is better than jail

It’s understandable that if you’re facing major legal penalties as a result of your drug and alcohol usage and are given the option to receive treatment at a substance addiction treatment center rather than going to jail, you would ask why rehab is preferable than prison. Aside from the obvious — you are not imprisoned, for starters — the basic response is as follows: You are not imprisoned. Being imprisoned does nothing to solve your situation. It serves as punishment for whatever law you committed while under the influence of drugs or alcohol, but it does not provide you with the assistance you need to address the drug and alcohol problems that led to your arrest in the first place.

  • According to the Mayo Clinic, “Alcohol use disorder (which includes a level that’s sometimes referred to as alcoholism) is a pattern of alcohol consumption that includes problems controlling your drinking, being preoccupied with alcohol, continuing to use alcohol even when it causes problems, needing to drink more to achieve the same effect, or experiencing withdrawal symptoms when you rapidly decrease or stop drinking.
  • “Drug addiction, also known as substance use disorder, is an illness that affects a person’s brain and behavior, resulting in an inability to manage the use of a legal or illicit drug or prescription,” according to the Mayo Clinic: “. When you are hooked to a substance, you may choose to continue using it despite the harm it causes.”

The Imbalance of Punishment vs. Treatment

That is the number one reason why rehab is preferable than prison: Your illness necessitates the need for medical treatment, not that you are a “bad” person who ought to be punished. The diagnosis of alcohol use disorder or drug use disorder does not automatically entitle the individual to a “get out of jail free pass.” If you’ve been convicted of a crime, you’ll still be required to provide restitution, which will include both monetary and physical compensation. However, if you do not treat such diseases, you will not be able to address the underlying source of the problem.

The nonprofit website Drug Policy Facts reports that law enforcement made 1,558,862 drug arrests in 2019, with 86.7 percent (1,351,533) of those arrests being for “mere possession of a controlled substance,” according to the website.

Furthermore, marijuana-related charges accounted for 35% of all drug arrests in 2019.

According to Kara Dansky, senior counsel for the American Civil Liberties Union, these figures appear to support her assertion that “this country has been fighting a failing war on drugs for decades.” The usage of illegal drugs has not decreased.

Instead of addressing our drug issue, we have evolved into a culture that appears to be indifferent to the lives of millions of people.” Identifying how many of those arrested truly need drug and alcohol treatment to address a problem, and how many of those arrested were given the chance to undergo such treatment through court-ordered or elective judicial diversion programs, is challenging.

The CDC reports that 7.8 percent (or 21.6 million individuals) of adults aged 12 and older need drug abuse treatment in the previous year in 2019.

In the United States, there are currently more than 3,000 drug court programs, according to the Department of Justice, which “implement a program aimed to minimize drug use relapse and criminal recidivism among defendants and offenders by providing a variety of services.” This includes risk and need assessment, judicial involvement, monitoring and supervision, progressive punishments and incentives, therapy and a variety of rehabilitation programs.” ” Aside from that, many court officials, ranging from district attorneys to judges at all levels of the justice system, applaud individuals who are charged with drug or alcohol charges for making the decision to seek treatment on their own.

According to the National Institute on Drug Abuse, “scientific research conducted since the mid-1970s has demonstrated that treatment of those with (substance use disorders) in the criminal justice system can change their attitudes, beliefs, and behaviors toward drug use; prevent relapse; and successfully remove themselves from a life of substance abuse and crime.”

Why Rehab Is Better Than Jail: A Chance to Get Better

Addicts and alcoholics in jail, unless they participate in some type of recovery program while incarcerated, are returned to their communities with no support system to encourage them to remain abstinent. Rehabilitation, on the other hand, provides addicts and alcoholics with a support system that encourages them to remain sober. They may have been abstinent while in prison (and in certain facilities, even that is not guaranteed), but they do not know how to maintain their sobriety once they are freed, which means their risks of recidivism remain high when they are released.

You might be interested:  Where Is Rehab Addict Rescue Filmed?

The treatment provided at a comprehensive treatment facility, as researchers point out in the Journal of the American Medical Association, can first and foremost educate addicted individuals about the nature of a problem that has guided them down a path of poor choices — including those that have resulted in arrests and legal charges — for months or even years: “Such persons may get upset when their attempts to restrict their own drug use are futile, and even after receiving treatment, many individuals grow irritated with what is frequently a protracted and precarious recovery process,” the authors write.

The neuroscience of the brain can assist the addicted individual in putting their sickness into a more understanding framework, allowing for more effective therapy to be implemented.” A variety of suggested procedures given in a treatment context illustrate why rehab is preferable to incarceration, according to the National Institute on Drug Abuse:

  • Individuals in treatment receive “behavioral therapies,” which may include “Cognitive Behavior Therapy” and other techniques
  • Medication to help with cravings, such asnaltrexone
  • And wrap-around services to assist them in reintegrating into society, such as an Intensive Outpatient Program and a Sober Living community
  • Trauma therapy to address issues related to their family of origin, grief, and other life events for which they have turned to alcohol or drugs as a means of coping

And, as the National Institute on Drug Abuse reminds out, the reasons why recovery is preferable to prison go beyond the individual who is faced with a decision between the two. It also reaps benefits for the communities to whom they owe reparation, including: “According to a report from the National Drug Intelligence Center, the cost of drug use to society in 2007 was $193 billion, with a significant portion of that figure — $ 113 billion — being associated with drug-related crime, which includes costs borne by victims of crime and costs borne by the criminal justice system.

According to the same analysis, the cost of treating drug use (including health-care expenses, hospitalizations, and government specialist treatment) was projected to be $14.6 billion, which is a small percentage of the entire social costs of drug abuse.” At the end of the day, the reason why rehab is preferable than incarceration is very obvious: It provides persons who have a drug or alcohol problem and have ran afoul of the law with an opportunity to treat their issues using medication.

In the end, whether or not they are sentenced to prison time, the experience of receiving drug and alcohol treatment for a legitimate illness that has the potential to be fatal is not only a wise decision, but it is also one that has the potential to yield long-term and positive life-changing results.

Rehab vs. Jail Time: How Drug Rehab Provides a Path to Recovery

The majority of narcotics are prohibited in every state in the United States. Among the substances included by this definition are cocaine, heroin, methamphetamine, and acid. Various other narcotics, including as marijuana, prescription pain relievers, and prescription amphetamines, are prohibited under specific circumstances. In the United States, the legal system is responsible with dealing with situations involving illegal drugs. Any variety of acts involving drugs or even alcohol might result in legal action being taken against the individual.

Any form of drug distribution is a major criminal violation.

Anyone who is associated with drugs in any of these ways is likely to be penalized, if not arrested, for their actions. Operating a motor vehicle while under the influence of alcohol or drugs can result in serious legal consequences as well.

Start Your Recovery at Peace Valley Recovery

  • Detoxification: treatment of withdrawal and cravings
  • Therapy: group and individual therapy
  • Plan for Aftercare: a thorough, tailored program Accepted insurances include: most major insurance companies
  • Housing: a sober living environment that is safe

Now is the time to call. It’s a FreeConfidential service! The exact charges that a person faces as a result of their drug-related acts are determined by a number of criteria. The type or types of drugs used, the amount of drugs used, the town or state in which the individual is located, and whether or not the person has been previously charged all have a factor. If you are forced to appear in court, you might be sentenced to anything as easy as community service or a fine, or something as serious as imprisonment or prison time.

Sure, some people who get themselves into difficulty because of substance abuse aren’t habitual drug or alcohol users.

However, this is not the situation for the vast majority of persons who are involved in judicial proceedings as a result of substance abuse.

Treating Drug Addiction with Time

Utilizing the criminal justice and prison systems to deal with persons who have drug issues is not the most successful strategy. Drug addiction is a serious problem with a long history. Getting off drugs is difficult, and people can’t just “quit using,” as some may imagine. For many people who are battling with addiction, drug treatment is a more preferable option than jail time rather than prison. When considering persons incarcerated for drug offenses, it is critical to weigh the advantages of rehabilitation against the disadvantages of prison term.

  1. Once someone has been charged with a drug-related offence, they will swiftly find themselves entangled in the criminal justice system.
  2. According to the Prison Policy Initiative, one out of every five persons jailed is serving time for a drug-related violation.
  3. For example, while seeking for housing or applying for a job, a background check is frequently performed.
  4. Someone who is attempting to break free from the cycle of addiction and restore their life Is incarceration the most effective option for persons suffering from drug use disorder?

Providing offenders with the option of attending drug treatment provides an alternate road to rehabilitation for people who might otherwise become entangled in the criminal justice system because of their addiction to drugs.

How Long Do Drug-Related Lockups Last?

There is an increasing number of persons serving prison sentences for drug-related offenses, many of which result from a struggle with drug addiction or addiction to other substances. One in every five persons convicted for drug-related offenses is detained for nonviolent offences such as drug possession, and 456,000 of those are imprisoned for such offenses. You may believe that possession does not result in a lengthy prison term, but the Brennan Center for Justice at New York University School of Law has shown otherwise.

People who are battling drug addiction are at risk when they are just in possession of narcotics.

Therefore, those who are battling a substance abuse problem might expect to spend months or even years in prison as a result of their addiction.

It becomes more difficult to overcome drug addiction when the problem is turned into a legal situation.

Jail Environments Do Little to Encourage Sobriety

Aside from that, there are relatively few therapy services available within the jail and prison systems. The medical care available to those who enter jail while under the influence of alcohol or drugs is limited. They frequently find themselves spending the most of their detox phase without much medical assistance for their drug withdrawal symptoms. As reported by the American Public Health Association, just 11 percent of persons battling with addiction receive treatment while incarcerated for their crimes.

  • Individuals with drug use disorders who are sentenced to prison receive minimal assistance in achieving or maintaining sobriety.
  • Most illegal narcotics may still be obtained from prisons in a variety of methods.
  • When someone is convicted of drug-related offenses, they are also given a criminal record, which makes life after prison more difficult for that person.
  • Increasing the difficulty of obtaining things like job and housing makes it more difficult to stop.

Drug Rehab: An Effective Alternative

People who are sentenced to prison are more likely to remain locked in the cycle of addiction than they are to be helped out of it. Others, such as individuals facing drug-related offenses, might benefit from court-ordered treatment programs, which are also available. Individuals suffering from substance use problems would benefit greatly from being sent to a drug treatment program rather than being imprisoned. Drug rehabilitation clinics exist only for the goal of assisting people in their efforts to break their addiction to drugs and alcohol.

People who are committed to attempting to quit using drugs will make the most of their time in an addiction treatment program, according to research.

A more proactive alternative than sending them to jail or prison is to place them in a treatment center for addiction. They’ll be surrounded by the kind of support that will put them on the path to a life of recovery from their addiction.

Drug Rehab vs. Incarceration

Those suffering from substance use issues will benefit little from spending time in prison. When they are released back into their surroundings, they are merely provided with “time out” and no skills to aid in their continued abstinence from substance abuse. People, on the other hand, frequently return to their old way of life with a new strategy in order to avoid being caught again. Some institutions provide programs, but they pale in contrast to the services provided by a specialized addiction treatment facility.

  1. The jail and prison systems will never be able to provide the same degree of assistance that can be found in a drug rehabilitation program.
  2. Many firms will not hire someone who has a criminal record because of this.
  3. Following their release from a treatment facility, as opposed to an institution such as jail or prison, they are more likely to obtain work.
  4. Patients are assisted in transitioning from the controlled atmosphere of rehab to the chaotic realities of regular life by the staff at treatment centers.

Promoting Recovery for Those at Risk

Individuals should be sent to drug rehab rather than being imprisoned in a penal facility, since this is a far more beneficial approach to recovery. They’re more likely to graduate from an addiction treatment program with life skills that will help them to reintegrate into society than they are to not graduate from treatment. People suffering from drug use disorders learn about the nature of their addiction during treatment. Jail, on the other hand, does not. Giving drug-related criminals the choice to go to treatment helps individuals who are most at risk of relapse get back on their feet.

Offenders can utilize their time in treatment to create the groundwork for a long-term rehabilitation by developing healthy habits.

They are able to sustain themselves and their family when they are re-integrated into society.

They will, however, find themselves on a path to recovery and away from the shackles of drug addiction if they are given the opportunity to undergo drug rehabilitation treatment.

Rehab vs. Jail Time: The Choice is Clear

The purpose of incarceration is to incentivize people to improve their conduct. It is not an effective method for people who have drug issues if the objective is to urge them to change via serving time in prison. Taking addicts who have a criminal record and placing them in prison would do little to alleviate their drug issue, experts say. If it were simple to stop using drugs, there would be no need for treatment centers. They exist only for the aim of assisting addicts in obtaining and maintaining a period of sobriety and recovery.

For people who have been charged with possession of a controlled substance, drug rehabilitation is a far more effective alternative.

Some inmates are given the choice to participate in an addiction treatment program instead of going to prison.

The inclusion of drug rehabilitation as a treatment option for those facing drug possession charges is a step in the right direction.

Drug Charges in Pennsylvania

Pennsylvania, like the Drug Enforcement Administration, divides substances into groups or “schedules” that are then classified further. The specific scheduling of a medication is determined by the danger it poses as well as the potential for addiction. In the state of California, the specific charges for drug-related offenses differ depending on which category or categories the narcotics belong into. The more dangerous the substance, the more dangerous the drug charge is almost always. In Pennsylvania, drug accusations are often divided into two categories: simple possession and possession with intent to deliver.

You might be interested:  What Happened With Windy City Rehab? (TOP 5 Tips)

Possession charges are filed against anyone who is accused of transporting illegal narcotics.

There are greater penalties associated with PWID charges.

Pennsylvania Drug Possession Offenses

The state of Pennsylvania regards drug possession and PWID offenses quite severe. Hard drug abuse is becoming increasingly prevalent in the state, resulting in a large number of deadly overdoses on a regular basis. The arrests for drug possession in Pennsylvania underscore the fact that reversing this trend is of fundamental concern to the state. The magnitude of the charges is determined by a number of factors, including:

  • Which class of drugs the individual has been detected with
  • The amount of money that a person has in his or her possession
  • It doesn’t matter if it’s possession or PWID. Instances of past drug-related criminal activity

For example, because they are the most hazardous narcotics, Schedule I, II, and III drugs are subject to the toughest punishments possible. These include drugs such as heroin, methamphetamine, opiates, benzodiazepines, cocaine, ecstasy, and LSD, among others. A $5,000 fine and up to a year in prison are possible consequences for a first-time offense, according to the law. If a person has previously committed infractions, the sanctions will be more severe. A PWID charge is more severe than a standard possession charge, which is especially true when dealing with strong narcotics.

People who distribute these sorts of medications are subjected to some of the most severe penalties. Someone who is arrested with the intent to distribute an opiate or opioid might face a fine of up to $250,000 and a jail sentence of up to 15 years.

“Drug Delivery Resulting in Death”

The rising number of overdose deaths prompted prosecutors in Pennsylvania to raise the amount of charges filed for “Drug Delivery Resulting in Death,” which is a felony. The accusation is brought against anyone who distributed drugs that were linked to a drug-related death. The crime was previously classed as third-degree murder before the disturbing number of deadly overdoses became apparent. Drug Delivery Resulting in Death is now a first-degree crime in the state of Pennsylvania, according to the law.

Possession of Drug Paraphernalia

It is not only unlawful to possess narcotics themselves, but it is also unlawful to carry drug accessories. Any drug paraphernalia discovered on a person will result in extra charges on top of any existing charges for drug possession or trafficking. If you are convicted of paraphernalia charges, you might face a fine as high as $2,500 and a year in prison.

Seeking Sobriety Before It’s Too Late

Achieving sobriety before reaching that stage is the most effective approach to avoid the dilemma of treatment vs prison time. Drug rehabilitation centers in Pennsylvania, such as Peace Valley Recovery, offer a route to recovery and well-being for those struggling with addiction. These clinics teach addicts how to live a drug-free life through a combination of counseling, therapy, holistic wellness, and sober activities. You may be looking for drug rehabilitation in Pennsylvania. Make contact with Peace Valley Recovery right now.

You will never need to turn to drugs again, and you will never need to feel alone again!

Give us a call right now.

Rehab vs. Jail Time: The Choice is Clear

The number of people who die from drug overdoses in the United States continues to rise at an alarming rate. In 2020, it is anticipated that over 90,000 overdose fatalities would be documented. Synthetic opioids such as fentanyl and carfentanil are a major contributor to the opioid crisis. The United States has a population of less than 5 percent of the world’s population, but it imprisons more people than any other nation every year, and it retains nearly 25 percent of the world’s total incarcerated population, making it the country with the highest prisoner rate of any country on the planet, according to the United Nations Development Programme.

Nonviolent drug offenders account for one in every five of those detained in state and federal prisons and local jails, or 20 percent of the total prison population.

Every year, more than 600,000 men and women are released from prison, and reports indicate that the current strategies employed by the justice system to achieve rehabilitation and increased public safety have been ineffective, with more than 80 percent of those who are released from state prisons being rearrested.

  1. and the majority of Americans feel that something needs to be done because the current state of the criminal justice system is not functioning.
  2. Substance abuse treatment through the criminal justice system provides a chance for recovery and will make a significant impact in decreasing the toll of the opioid epidemic.
  3. It is defined by obsessive drug seeking and continuous drug use despite harmful consequences that create long-term changes in brain structure and function.
  4. SUD is a chronic relapsing brain condition that affects persons who have it.
  5. According to research, MAT is at least twice as successful as abstinence-based therapy, which does not contain drugs, in treating addiction.
  6. Incarcerated persons have the right to medical treatment for substance abuse disorders, and jails and prisons, as government facilities, are required to provide that care.
  7. It is up to the community to demand it.
  8. If this does not change, the opioid crisis will continue unabated.
  9. Individuals suffering from mental health and substance use difficulties have found themselves in and out of jail on a regular basis.
  10. Criminalization-focused approaches to drug use are not based on evidence and have resulted in a large number of people being locked up.
  11. In addition, the way officials/authorities view and deal with illicit drug users is an unintentional effect of the war on drugs.

It has been proven that the use of MAT in the prison system is effective and helps to create a culture that ensures those with a criminal history are better equipped for productive, law-abiding futures, secure meaningful employment, achieve true closure after punishment is completed, and avoid criminal behavior in the future.

Reincarceration rates were reduced by 48 percent in one California jail after inmates received substance addiction therapy.

Everyone involved in the criminal justice system has an ethical obligation to acknowledge substance use disorder (SUD) and addiction not as a moral failing but as a curable condition.

Society, stakeholders, all levels of government, and prison administrators must open their hearts and minds to the fact that there are scientifically proven, evidence-based treatment options available, and allow prisons to become an essential touchpoint in the process of assisting people successfully navigate their way back to health and independence.

  1. Real drug rehabilitation and Medically Assisted Treatment are easily accessible in jail, but community involvement is essential to reforming the prison system and making them more freely accessible.
  2. The purpose of imprisonment is to punish criminal activity, discourage future unlawful action, and encourage people to alter their ways.
  3. Obviously, if stopping drugs were simple, there would be no need for therapy, but this is not the case.
  4. That is not to suggest that it is impossible to stop using drugs while in prison without therapy, but there are considerably better options available.
  5. Punishment also fails as a public safety intervention for offenders whose criminal behavior is directly tied to drug use.
  6. The brain of a drug abuser is hardwired to correlate addictive substances with feelings of pleasure or comfort.
  7. The rise in the number of drug-abusing offenders underscores the need for treatment programs for those who are involved in the criminal justice system, which must be implemented immediately.

Opioidagonist therapy is a form of medication-assisted treatment that involves the administration of Schedule 1 opioid medicines like as methadone, buprenorphine, or Suboxone.

In order to assure patient safety, medications are prescribed in a controlled, supervised clinical environment.

It is a very successful treatment that improves clinical outcomes while also decreasing illegal opioid usage, overdose deaths, and costs.

Worst of all, the majority of correctional facilities discontinue opioid agonist therapy once an inmate is admitted into the justice system.

However, only a small number of prisons provide MAT because criminal justice officials do not understand the science of opioid use disorder and how to provide effective treatment for it.

Prisons do not prioritize medical and behavioral care, leaving convicts without resources or therapy.

People who represent minimal threat to public safety are frequently arrested, jailed, and re-incarcerated, which has immediate moral and financial consequences.

Putting more drug law offenders behind prisons for longer lengths of time has resulted in significant expenses for taxpayers, but it has not resulted in a demonstrable increase in public safety as a result of those investments.

Restorative justice has been shown to be effective in several studies, and if even a tiny number of persons convicted of drug charges were sentenced to a community-based treatment program instead of jail, the criminal justice system would save billions of dollars.

It is estimated that every dollar spent on MAT or SUD treatment saves $4 in health care expenditures and $7 in criminal justice costs, according to a research cited by the Treatment First Washingtoncoalition.

SUD patients who undergo treatment are significantly less likely to commit crimes, incur re-arrest and trial expenses, and are far more likely to become useful members of their communities than those who do not.

It is imperative that prisons provide a greater emphasis on mental health care, vocational training, support groups, and ongoing education.

This group of people frequently enters jail as a productive member of society and exits as a hardened criminal, since our prisons are changing people’s life — but not in a positive way — at the present time.

Because convicts will be re-entering society at some point in their life, the criminal justice system has a moral duty to return them to society in a better state than when they first arrived, not a worse state.

The UN Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC) has recognized several major negative “unintended consequences” of the drug war, including stigmatization, discrimination, and mass imprisonment, in addition to the failure of the drug war.

How does it function?

Deterrence?

Redemption?

Supporting medically assisted treatment in jails and prisons, as well as harm reduction initiatives such as naloxone training and distribution, can make a difference.

References People prefer rehabilitation to incarceration, according to polls.

The ways in which America’s prisons are contributing to the opioid epidemic Vox – March of this year A federal court rules that a jail must provide inmate addiction treatment, setting a precedent NPR – May 19, 2019.

Meeting the Needs of Individuals with Substance Use Disorders: Strategies for Correctional Institutions Counties of the United States of America – 2018

Rehabilitation vs. Incarceration

The statistics on rehabilitation vs incarceration demonstrate that people who receive addiction treatment from a facility such as an Orange County rehab are in a better position than those who are confined to a prison or jail cell. Despite the fact that the argument over rehabilitation vs jail for drug-related offenses continues to rage, it is now virtually unanimously acknowledged that rehabilitation is the most successful, most humanitarian, and most cost-efficient strategy available. When someone with an alcohol use disorder or a drug use disorder joins a treatment center, they have the opportunity to participate in holistic therapy that addresses their body, mind, and spirit, as well as evidence-based addiction treatment options.

Incarceration, on the other hand, serves primarily as a punitive measure rather than as a means of rehabilitation.

The primary goal of incarceration is to punish someone for breaking the law, rather than to ensure that they become an useful and functioning member of society once they are released from detention or prison.

Consequently, we find ourselves in an unusual situation in which the vast majority of people agree that those who commit drug-related crimes deserve punishment in the form of prison time, despite the fact that incarceration does nothing to address the underlying causes of alcoholism or drug addiction.

In the event that you require assistance with an addiction problem, please contact our staff as soon as possible.

You might be interested:  What Did Leah From Teen Mom Go To Rehab For?

Rehabilitation vs. Incarceration – The Facts

The decision on whether to imprison or rehabilitate people guilty of drug-related crimes is subtle and, to a large extent, arbitrary. We believe it is prudent to begin with a logical examination of the information available to us.

Statistical Lens

First, we’ll focus on the final outcome of first rehabilitation and then jail before delving further into the reasons why addicts commit crimes in the first place.

Drug Treatment Statistics

According to the yearly NSDUH (National Survey on Drug Use and Health) survey conducted by SAMHSA (the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration) beginning in 2009, the following data on the treatment of drug addiction were gathered.

  • As a result of these findings, 23.5 million over-12s sought treatment for everything from alcohol use disorder to drug abuse disorder. This equates to around 9 percent of the population. 2.6 million of these individuals sought and got therapy in a specialist treatment center, representing just 11 percent of those who need care
  • And It is estimated that 1.8 million persons were admitted to treatment centers for alcohol use disorder and drug use disorder in 2008, according to the SAMHSA Treatment Episode Data Set. The majority of these admissions (41 percent) were related to alcohol misuse. An estimated 20 percent of all drug-related hospitalizations were caused by heroin and other opioids. Drug-related admissions resulting from marijuana use were a close second, accounting for 17 percent of all drug-related admissions in 2008.

While the majority of people who seek addiction treatment have positive outcomes, it appears that the most difficult part of the process is getting them into treatment in the first place. However, the same cannot be true for the constantly increasing prison population.

Incarceration Statistics

Following that, some depressing facts about incarceration.

  • In the United States, a person gets arrested for drug possession every 25 seconds, according to the FBI. Since 1980, the overall number of arrests for drug possession has more than quadrupled in the United States. At its peak in 2015, the number of people arrested for drug possession had reached 1.3 million each year, about six times the total number of people arrested for drug sales. Twenty percent of the jail population is detained on drug-related offences, accounting for a total of 1.1 million people. For drug-related offenses, an additional 1 million individuals are on parole or probation
  • Among those who have just been released from prison, overdose is the primary cause of death. Ex-inmates are 13 times more likely to die in the first week after being released than the general population during this time period. In the case of drug-related offenses, it has been demonstrated that incarceration has minimal influence on rates of substance abuse. Contrary to popular belief, jail has minimal effect on improving public safety. However, although crime rates have been moving downwards since 1990, experts believe that factors other than incarceration are responsible for between 75% and 100% of the decreases.

Call our staff at 866.330.9449 right now if you are suffering from an addiction issue.

Why Do Most Addicts Commit Crimes? Is it Really Because of Drugs?

Call our staff at 866.330.9449 right now if you are struggling with an addiction. On the basis of current estimates, between 30% and 50% of all acquisitive crime is associated with illicit drug addiction. Beyond this, however, there are more connections between drugs and crime than you may initially think. The following are some of the most typical legal concerns that arise as a result of the consumption of illegal narcotics and alcoholic beverages:

  • Possession of illegal drugs
  • Drug sales
  • Offenses involving violence done while under the influence of alcohol or drugs
  • Assaults, domestic assaults, manslaughters, and murders in which drugs are involved are all prohibited. Infractions involving driving while under the influence of alcohol or drugs
  • Interactions between drug traffickers are violent

Differences between Rehabilitation and Incarceration

When it comes to those who suffer from substance use disorders, jail does little to treat or support the problem. In a crucial sense, jail just functions as a prolonged time-out before the individual is released back into the same environment, with no new skills at their disposal to fight the temptations that lie in wait for them upon their return home. Some jails have substance abuse treatment programs, but the level of care provided in these institutions does not compare to that provided in dedicated alcohol and drug addiction treatment centers.

  1. In a jail environment, it is impossible to obtain the same level of input.
  2. You’ll be able to get assistance with concerns linked to getting and keeping a job by visiting this page.
  3. As an example, consider someone who has been released from prison for a drug charge and is now coping with the problems of obtaining job in a competitive economy as an ex-offender (see Figure 1).
  4. The top treatment centers make certain that you either transition to a less severe level of care or that you receive the appropriate amount of aftercare following your therapy.
  5. We wouldn’t need specialist treatment centers if it were simple to stop using alcohol or drugs.
  6. One and only reason for their existence is to make it simpler for persons addicted to alcohol and drugs to detox from their addictions, withdraw from them, and begin their recovery.

Treat trauma

According to the World Health Organization’s information page onMental Health and Prisons: A Guide for Policymakers and Practitioners

  • As a result of violence, overcrowding, privacy concerns, a lack of productive activities and forced solitude and isolation, as well as uncertainty about future possibilities and a lack of health services, prisons are not beneficial to mental health. Those who are jailed are at a greater risk of suicide, particularly when the suicide is linked to depression

Food options

People who are hooked to alcohol or drugs are almost always suffering from nutritional deficits of some kind. A rehabilitation facility will give nutritional guidance, and in the event of residential rehabilitation, meals will be supplied.

The food served in jail will not be tailored to support the systems of persons in recovery from addiction, and the selection of food will be limited and of lower quality than that available in the community.

Freedom

No one could credibly claim that those convicted of opiate trafficking do not deserve to spend time in jail as a result of their conviction. There are several laws in place that impose severe penalties on people who are found guilty of these drug-related offenses when they are discovered. What most people are unaware of is that the vast majority of drug offenders sentenced to prison are not found guilty of drug trafficking. In reality, possession is the charge in 80 percent of drug-related criminal prosecutions, according to the Bureau of Justice Statistics.

This implies that the judge will have no leeway in selecting how to punish a person who has been charged with this sort of offense.

Become a Better Person

Rehabilitation is about being a better person in all meanings of the word. On the other hand, regardless of whether or not jail time has a therapeutic component, it is debatable how many people leave prison a better person than when they initially arrived.

Fight Addiction With Rehab VS Jail

We’ll take a look at how more severe sentences are inflaming the issue and fanning the flames of the debate over addiction treatment vs. jail time right now.

Federal Court Systems Giving Harsher Sentences

We’ll take a look at how increasingly severe sentences are inflaming the issue and stoking the flames of the debate over addiction treatment vs jail time.

How Incarceration Can Affect the Individual and the Family

For those who support the use of jail time as a deterrent for those convicted of drug offenses, it is important to recognize the impact that incarceration has on the entire family, not just the one who has been sentenced. Marriages become strained, families lose the primary earner, and children lose their parents to the criminal justice system, often for years at a time. Individuals in recovery, on the other hand, may maintain their ties to their families while receiving the care they require to go on in a healthy manner.

The Cost of Rehabilitation vs Incarceration

It is estimated that drug rehabilitation rather than jail might save billions of dollars. Take into consideration the following:

  • It is estimated that drug treatment rather than jail might save billions of dollars. As an example, consider this:

Why is Rehab Better Than Jail?

Assuming that addiction is an illness, persons who are suffering from it should be treated with kindness and understanding. Now is the time to get treatment for an addiction issue. Please contact us at 866.330.9449 as soon as possible. As a result of the fact that many drug-related offences for possession are basically victimless crimes, it becomes nonsensical to continue to overcrowd our jails with people who would benefit from addiction treatment. The long-term outcomes of this method are also likely to be preferable than the current state of affairs in which we find ourselves.

FAQ

It makes more sense to give addicts a chance to cope with their sickness and heal than than sending them to prison. If we accept the premise that addiction is a sickness, then we should treat it as such by the government and the rest of society. Why is it necessary to spend so much time and money prosecuting individuals who are unwell after they have been caught for a crime? Instead, we should treat them as if they had an illness. We don’t punish folks who have other medical issues in the same way that we do cancer patients.

In contrast, a criminal caught with a little amount of the substance for personal use is more than likely a good candidate for therapy rather than imprisonment.

An inpatient rehab center provides a considerably superior environment for addicts who are recovering from their addiction.

Treatment will be divided into slots for treatment, counseling sessions, 12-step program meetings, meals, recreation, and free time, with each slot lasting around one hour. In the evenings, customers will be asked to be in their rooms at a pre-determined hour each night.

2) Is rehab expensive?

The cost of rehabilitation varies based on the facilities provided and the location of the facility. Aspects of the treatment program’s breadth and character will also have an influence on its cost. Residential treatment costs between $2000 to $7500 for a 30-day program in the most basic form. Most typical facilities charge between $10,000 and $20,000 per month, depending on the facility. Upscale rehabs might cost upwards of $25,000 per month. Consider outpatient addiction therapy if you want to save a lot of money on your addiction treatment.

In most cases, outpatient therapy will also be covered by your health insurance policy.

3) How do I get into rehab?

First and foremost, you should seek recommendations from friends and relatives. Look for treatment centers in your area on the internet. Contact the Renaissance Recovery Center, located in Orange County, at 866.330.9449 to expedite the process of finding a facility.

4) Should drug offenders be incarcerated?

The true question is not whether or not someone should be punished for breaching the law, but rather whether or not they should be punished. Rather than whether someone who commits a crime solely as a result of drug addiction receives an appropriate punishment by being forced to coexist in a community of often violent criminals, the question is whether they receive the necessary help to recover from their addiction. The obligatory addiction treatment option, on the other hand, would almost likely generate greater long-term results.

Rehab is the Goal: Get Treatment Today

If you’re battling with an addiction to alcohol, prescription medications, or illegal substances, you should seek help immediately to avoid getting into legal difficulties. Without the expense or difficulty of inpatient treatment, our evidence-based outpatient treatment programs can assist you in addressing alcohol use disorder or drug use disorder. You can conquer addiction with a mix of medication-assisted treatment and psychotherapy, such as cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), before you find yourself in legal trouble or behind bars.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *